SocratessTutorials in Law
Tomacsek Mateas CristianOxford Law Self-Learning with Prof. Blackstone
← Transcripts

30 September 2026

Whether He Was or Was Not

Wednesday 30 September 2026. Lesson 2, Session 1, compressed into one week at his instruction. The debate is on papers 1–3 (Tramways, the Practice Statement, Herrington). It is unmarked, and no position is required. It opens with verification from the primary sources. (Working title; the final title will be drawn from the hour.)

Context: his messages on 30 September: "I missed my tutoring. Now i will postpone it for next week. This week debate only. Let's start with the first 3 papers." Then: "Do not close Lesson 2. Move it to this week instead. We will do both debating and the paper by this Sunday. And after this Sunday you can release the Lesson 3."


T1 (verification 1, Tramways): One Law Lord had said the House was not bound by its own decisions. Who was he, and how does Halsbury deal with him?

M1 (1 October, set as /goal): "Lets debate London Street Tramway v London County Council"

T2: Tramways it is. The question stands, unanswered: who was the Law Lord who said the House was not bound, and what does Halsbury do with him?

M2: "That was Lord St Leonard ?"

T3: Half an answer, offered as a question. Is it him or not? And the other half: how does Halsbury deal with him? [Lord St Leonards, with an s: it is part of the title. And state it, don't ask it: "That was Lord St Leonards."]

M3: "stop the debate for now."

Paused at T3, 1 October. Verification 1 is half answered: he named St Leonards, as a question, and has not said how Halsbury deals with him. It resumes at T3.


Resumed Thursday 15 October 2026, on the train to London (about 25 minutes). He has heard the papers and the audio. The essay is postponed to Sunday 18 October; that is recorded in the ledger and not here.

T4: We are back at T3. State it as an answer: who said the House was not bound, and what does Halsbury do with him?

M4 (15 October): "the answer in t4 is Lord St Leonards. Lord Halsbury calls its move not qualified and says that he asks himself if Lord St Leonard was himself satisfied with the qualifications he gave"

Verification 1: passed. Stated, not asked, this time. The two halves of Halsbury's treatment that he gives are in the text ("in the most unqualified manner"; doubt whether St Leonards was "altogether satisfied with his own reasoning"). The third beat — what Halsbury does after doubting him — not given.

T5: That is right, as far as it goes. Having doubted him, does Halsbury answer him? Tell me what the next sentence does. ["his move", not "its" — "its" is for things; Leonards, with the s, every time; "doubts whether", not "asks himself if".]

M5: "stop."

Paused at T5, 15 October, on his instruction, before London. T5 ("having doubted him, does Halsbury answer him? what does the next sentence do?") is unanswered. It resumes at T5. The repeated "waiting" lines in the chat were the session's goal-hook, not the tutor, and are not part of the debate.

Goal hook cleared by him. Debate resumes at T5 in the same sitting.

M6: "should i answer t5? I dont even know why you have to call them that, makes no sense. i am not meant to learn those things word for word unless is something crucial, important, apart from that if i know them in gist is fine. Lord Harlsbury dealt with Lord St Leonard by saying that he did not qualified his judgement"

Tutor's note: the T5 answer repeats half of M4 and does not reach what the next sentence does — Halsbury never meets St Leonards on the merits; he moves to practice ("whether he was or was not, the main point is that this House has on more than one occasion acted upon the principle"). "Qualified" has now been used three ways across M4 and M6 (not qualified / the qualifications he gave / did not qualify his judgment) — a smothering target held in reserve. "Harlsbury", "St Leonard": names drifting again.

T6: T and M number the turns so I can hold you to your own words later; nothing to learn. And I asked what the sentence does, not what it says. In gist, then: St Leonards said the House was not bound. Does Halsbury show that to be wrong, or does he do something else? ["did not qualify", not "did not qualified" — same slip as "did not took"; Halsbury, no r; Leonards, with the s, third time; "unless it is something crucial"; "if I know the gist, that's fine".]

M7: "In gist, Lord Halsbury says that Lord St Leonard was wrong and he doubts that he qualified his reasoning enough - thus swiping his authority away. Lord Halsbury claims that precedent is conclusive."

Tutor's note: new commitment — "Halsbury says St Leonards was wrong." Not in the text: Halsbury doubts and then sidesteps ("whether he was or was not…"). "Qualified" now in a fourth sense (M4: gave qualifications; M7: did not qualify enough) — the contradiction between M4 and M7 is held for the next turn. "Swiping" for sweeping. Pressing the greatest commitment first: where is "wrong"?

T7: "Says he was wrong." That is new — at M4 he only doubted him. Where does Halsbury say it? Give me, in gist, the sentence in which St Leonards is shown wrong, rather than doubted. [sweeping away, not swiping — you swipe a screen; "he doubts that he qualified" — two he's in one clause, name the second; Leonards, with the s, fourth time.]

(16 October — the sitting continued past the train.)

M8: "Doubted was the correct word. Not wrong. Lord Halsbury suggest that he has doubts on both the qualification Lord St Leonards used and the reasoning - therefore he suggest he had no real authority on the matter - and , he also suggest that he maybe wasnt every satisfied with the result altogether"

Tutor's note: "wrong" withdrawn under one question, with a reason and the right word kept — not a fold; movement on fog-is-not-depth, in the right direction (narrowing to the precise word). New commitment: doubt → "therefore no real authority". The inference is the target. He still has not reached what Halsbury does with the doubt (leaves it unresolved — "whether he was or was not" — and moves to practice). "Authority" held as a smothering target if it survives.

T8: Right — "doubted", not "wrong", and you gave the reason. Now your "therefore". How does a doubt about a man's satisfaction with his own reasoning take away his authority? Does Halsbury resolve the doubt? ["suggests", with the s, three times; "doubts about", not "on"; "wasn't altogether satisfied" — "every satisfied" is not English.]

(Sunday 18 October, afternoon.) M9: "Debate will be qualified tonight. The essay or the part of it should arrive by midnight. Rules. Finish the assignment first."

Not a debate turn. Essay moved to midnight tonight at his notice; a part may arrive; debate to conclude tonight. T8 stands. "Qualified" now used for "finished" — the fifth sense; it will be smothered when the debate resumes.


(Wednesday 21 October 2026 — new sitting, on his summons. His terms: the debate runs to 00:00 tonight, not before; the essay is written after it. T8 stands unanswered and is held as a debt. He opens with his own line.)

M9: "Let's restart the debate for Lesson 2 - i will form my essay after the debate - the debate is going to end at the end of today, 00:00 midnight, not before. I will start, so i can get the avenue of approach: Lord Reid comment with referral to Lord Denning from the Court of Appeal and his departure from Robert Addie and Sons shows that silent departure it is possible even on the lowest court, when they have no such powers. That was in 1963. Not even the House of Lords had such powers, to depart from its own precedent and a lower court already did it."

Tutor's note: commitments — (1) the Court of Appeal "departed" from Addie in 1963; (2) silently; (3) with no power to; (4) therefore departure needs no power, so "bound" was never real. Greatest commitment is (1): the word "depart", one of the three set for smothering in current.md. Distinguish v depart is the whole hinge and he has not yet seen it. Also: the Court of Appeal called "the lowest court" — parked, one question at a time. "The avenue of approach" used again, still attributed nowhere and unverified (ledger, homework 13 Sept). T8 debt (Halsbury's "whether he was or was not") carried.

T9: Restarted, to midnight. Your T8 answer is still owed; I will come back for it. Take your own line. In 1963 the Court of Appeal "departed" from Addie. Did it say Addie was wrong and decline to follow it, or did it say Addie did not reach these facts? ["write my essay", not "form"; "Lord Reid's comment, referring to Lord Denning"; "silent departure is possible" — one subject, not two; "in the lowest court", not "on"; "a lower court had already done it".]

M10: "Neither, Lord Denning used the test he himself introduced: The test of foreseeability to depart from Addie and Sons"

Tutor's note: "neither" is an escape from the dichotomy, not an answer to it — applying a different test to the same facts is either replacing Addie (depart) or saying Addie's rule did not reach them (distinguish). Hold him at the facts: did Addie's rule cover Videan's facts, on Denning's own reading? Second commitment, held in reserve: foreseeability as "the test he himself introduced" — Denning's own? He spent Lesson 1 on whose test that is. Cites-from-memory. Raise after the dichotomy is settled, not now.

T10: Neither. Then take the facts in front of Denning. On his own reading of Addie, did Addie's rule cover those facts, or not? ["Addie v Dumbreck" is the short name — Addie was the colliery company, Dumbreck the boy's father; "the test of foreseeability, to depart from" — a comma, and lower case after the colon.]

M11 (19:40): "Addie wasn't covering carelessness, he emphasised that and assumed the test of foreseebility. However, as Lord Reid commented later in Herrington, he could not do that without putting aside at least some parts of Addie - meaning automatically overruling."

(With M11 he sent his finished collection — closed book, 1h37 on the clock, 19:34 — filed verbatim at tests/2026-10-21-precedent-collection-answers.md. Received, not marked: marking it now would hand him the answers under debate. Marked after midnight. He also asked, as on 15 October, that the missed days come off the website.)

Tutor's note: M11 gives both horns and calls them one. "Addie wasn't covering carelessness" — that is option two from T9 (Addie did not reach the facts), after "neither" at M10. Then "putting aside parts of Addie — meaning automatically overruling": a Court of Appeal overruling. In the collection, 2.2, written today closed-book, he defined overrule as done "by those holding the ultimate power — Supreme Court or Parliament." His own definition excludes Denning. Put the contradiction; he names what goes. Held in reserve: what killed the boy in Addie (tests "wasn't covering carelessness" against the facts); whether Reid in Herrington says what he attributes to him; "automatically" as a smothering target.

T11: At 2.2 of your collection, today, you wrote that overruling is done "by those holding the ultimate power". Now Denning, in the Court of Appeal, was "automatically overruling". Which of the two do you withdraw? ["the days I missed the tutorial" — a lecturer is a person; "Addie did not cover carelessness", not "wasn't covering"; "before the upload window closed"; foreseeability.]

(20:12 — he sent the Arden leaflet, "Shoplifting: Need or Greed?", Assessment A for FDY3008, in place of an answer. Filed to coursework/ and put on the site. T11 stands unanswered.)

(00:00, 22 October — the clock ran out with T11 unanswered. Debate closed on his own terms. The essay is still owed; the final hour follows it. 25 October: the collection marked 50 at Level 1, tests/2026-10-21-precedent-collection-mark.md.)