The ledger
Progress
What Socratess keeps between tutorials. The ladder moves on what happens in the hour, not on marks.
Standing
| student | Mateas |
|---|---|
| level | 1 — first weeks of an undergraduate degree |
| term | Michaelmas, Lesson 3 — weekly from 25 October 2026, on his proposal: two |
| tutorials sat | 2 (23 August; 25 October) |
| promotion rule | on observed behaviour in the hour — never on marks, never on time. |
| need for recovery — his rule, 28 october 2026 | never put a case in front of him without a |
What moves you up a level
- ☑stated a ratio correctly and unprompted — 1st occasion: 13 Sept 2026, S4/S9 (narrow rule identified as the ratio unasked; stated whole from notes, declared). Needs a second consecutive occasion. 25 Oct: Dunlop's rule stated correctly (M13) but looked up mid-hour and prompted — not counted.
- ☐distinguished a case on its facts without being told to — not yet: 13 Sept clear-glass distinction was on a hypothetical the tutor set. 25 Oct: "she sued in tort, not in contract" (M15) — led there by T14; not counted.
- ☑said "I don't know" instead of fogging, at least once — 1st occasion: 13 Sept 2026, S6 (clear-glass hypothetical; said it, then reasoned). 2nd occasion: 25 Oct 2026, M10 (which decision of the House held the privity rule — "I don't know", then found Dunlop). Met.
The term ahead
- 1.Case law technique — the ratio decidendi
- 2.Precedent — bindingness and departure (the 1966 Practice Statement, London Tramways)
- 3.Statutory interpretation
- 4.Jurisprudence begins: Austin's command theory and Hart's critique (the withdrawn 15 August set is reused here)
- 5–8.Hart–Fuller; natural law; onward as the tutorials dictate.
- 3.Departing openly — Knauer v Ministry of Justice [2016] UKSC 9 and Lord Reed's 2023 lecture (set 25 October; the break of 25 October was on which decision binds which court)
- 4.Statutory interpretation on a text born from a case — the Occupiers' Liability Act 1984, s 1, which put Herrington into statute (the banked Smith v Hughes / Fisher v Bell set is cut to two items and folded in)
- 5.Duty of care and how to use precedent in negligence — Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire [2018] UKSC 4
- 6.Offer and acceptance as case law technique — Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256 (CA)
- 7.– onward as the tutorials dictate; a monthly essay on a harder question ties the month.
Michaelmas: legal method first, then jurisprudence — re-sequenced 15 August 2026 on his objection (correct) that legal philosophy cold in week 1 outruns a first-year; at Oxford the Jurisprudence paper is a Finals subject. He reports private reading in the area (Austin, Hart), so theory enters at week 4 rather than later. The arc is a guide, not a rail — each week's topic still follows from where the last tutorial broke down: Revised 25 October 2026, on his proposal, after the Lesson 2 hour: jurisprudence comes out of the arc for now — he enters contract and tort at Arden knowing nothing of them, and the method is better exercised on their cases. Lessons are weekly. The arc from here, each Lesson still following from where the last broke: All items verified when set, not before.
The record
| Date | Topic | Level mark | Finals mark | Wound that recurred |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-08-23 | Case law technique — the ratio decidendi | 59 | n/a at L1 (see report) | Fog is not depth ("sentiment") |
| 2026-09-13 | Donoghue revision, full, unmarked — Lesson 1 closed | — | — | Broke on bound (five answers, none withdrawn; theory/reality split; open texture named at S2, never applied) — a Level 3 rung, correct place to break. Level 1 met on both rules and the dissent. "Reid confirms precedent is a myth" — cites-from-memory. Report reports/2026-09-13-donoghue-revision.md |
| 2026-10-25 | Precedent — final hour on the essay; Lesson 2 closed | 46 | n/a at L1 (see report) | Essay 1,015 words of 1,500, two footnotes, footnote 1 a case that does not exist (ceiling 54, fail rule not applied — misnamed, not fabricated). Asserted Videan's outcome without knowing it (M5–M6). Withdrew "overruling" for Denning with a reason (M7). "I don't know" clean (M10) — 2nd occasion. Donoghue as "departure" collapsed to "from conventional wisdom" (M16). Flip: four honest sentences, no authority. Broke on a Level 2 rung — which decision binds which court. Report reports/2026-10-25-only-the-engine-departs.md |
| 2026-10-21 | Precedent debate resumed (T9–T11) and the closed-book collection, 1h37 | 50 (collection) | — | Debate closed at midnight with T11 unanswered — distinguish v depart, put three ways, never answered. Collection: verdicts on law never stated; would not write the thesis as a sentence (1.1, 5.1, 5.4, 6.1). Young v Bristol Aeroplane misstated. "Sentiment" again. Mark tests/2026-10-21-precedent-collection-mark.md |
| 2026-09-12 | Donoghue revision, short, unmarked | — | — | Could not state the neighbour principle when asked four ways ("implicit", "the citizen", "the understanding of that speech"). Refused "I don't know" and was right on the sentiment sentence — not fog. Transcript transcripts/2026-09-12-donoghue-revision-short.md. Full debate 13 Sept |
What Socratess himself holds
Stated positions, so there is something to disagree with to his face.
- ·Ratio is rule-based, not fact-based — Cross over Goodhart.
- ·Constructive reinterpretation by later courts is real but bounded: the existence of overruling proves something was fixed.
- ·Rule-scepticism is a disappointed absolutism.
Points conceded to you
| Date | Point conceded |
|---|---|
| 2026-09-13 | "Moral availability" debt cancelled: said in the 23 Aug hour, no transcript kept; the tutor could not reproduce the context and does not hold him to a phrase the tutor did not record. |